New Ebook on Zeran v. AOL, the Most Important Section 230 Case (Techdirt Cross-Post)
Section 230 has become a mainstream discussion topic, but unfortunately many discussants don’t actually understand it well (or at all). To address this knowledge gap, co-editors Profs. Eric Goldman (Santa Clara Law) and Jeff Kosseff (U.S. Naval Academy) have released an ebook, called “Zeran v. America Online,” addressing many aspects of Section 230. You can download the ebook for free at:
- SSRN
- SCU Digital Commons (also available as an ePub)
- Google Play
Zeran v. AOL is the most important Section 230 case of all time. The Zeran case was the first federal appellate decision interpreting Section 230, and its breathtakingly broad sweep turbocharged the rise of Web 2.0–with all of its strengths and weaknesses.
In recognition of Zeran’s importance, in 2017, Profs. Goldman and Kosseff helped assemble an essay package to honor the case’s 20th anniversary. They gathered two dozen essays from some of the most knowledgeable Section 230 experts. The essays address the case’s history and policy implications. Initially, Law.com published the essay package but then unexpectedly paywalled the essays after 6 months.
The new Zeran v. America Online ebook restores the 2017 essay package into a new and easy-to-read format. Together, they are a great entry point into the debates about Section 230, including how we got here and what’s at stake.
To supplement the essay package, the ebook compiles an archive of the key documents in the Zeran v. AOL litigation (with bonus coverage of Zeran’s case against radio station KRXO). Many of these materials have not previously been publicly available in electronic format. The case archives should be of interest both to historians and students of precedent-setting litigation tactics.
Section 230 will likely remain hotly debated, but the debates won’t be productive until we develop a shared understanding of what the law says and why. Ideally, this ebook will advance those goals.
* * *
The book’s table of contents:
About the Book
Advertisements Posted to AOL’s Michigan Military Movement Forum
The Essays
Commemorating the 20th Anniversary of Internet Law’s Most Important Judicial Decision
Eric Goldman and Jeff Kosseff
‘Zeran v. AOL’ and Its Inconsistent Legacy
Ian C. Ballon
Section 230 Keeps Platforms for Defamation and Threats Highly Profitable
Ann Bartow
Policy Architecture and Internet Freedom
Jerry Berman
Sex, Scandal and Intermediary Liability: Imagining Life Without ‘Zeran v. AOL’
Hillary Brill
How the Scam Artists at Stratton Oakmont Made ‘Zeran’ Possible and Unwittingly Saved the Internet
Robert J. Butler
Serendipity and Internet Law: How the ‘Zeran v. AOL’ Landmark Almost Wasn’t
Patrick J. Carome and Cary A. Glynn
20 Years of Protecting Intermediaries: Legacy of ‘Zeran’ Remains a Critical Protection for Freedom of Expression Online
Cindy Cohn and Jamie Williams
How the Supreme Court Ignored the Lesson of ‘Zeran’ and Screwed Up Copyright Law on the Internet
Roger Allan Ford
Moral Hazard on Stilts: ‘Zeran’s’ Legacy
Mary Anne Franks
The Possible Redundancy of §230
Brian L. Frye
The First Hard Case: ‘Zeran v. AOL’ and What It Can Teach Us About Today’s Hard Cases
Cathy Gellis
Who Cyber-Attacked Ken Zeran, and Why?
Eric Goldman
No ESC
James Grimmelmann
The Satellite Has No Conscience: §230 in a World of ‘Alternative Facts’
Laura A. Heymann
The Non-Inevitable Breadth of the ‘Zeran’ Decision
Samir C. Jain
The Judge Who Shaped the Internet
Jeff Kosseff
Zeran’s Failed Lawsuit Against an Oklahoma Radio Station
Robert D. Nelon
The Chilling Effect Claims in ‘Zeran v. AOL’
Jonathon W. Penney
‘Zeran v. America Online’ and the Development of Trolling Culture
Aaron Schwabach
‘Zeran v. AOL’: The Anti-Circumvention Tool
Maria Crimi Speth
The UK’s Broad Rejection of the §230 Model
Gavin Sutter
‘AOL v. Zeran’: The Cyberlibertarian Hack of §230 Has Run Its Course
Olivier Sylvain
CDA 230 Then and Now: Does Intermediary Immunity Keep the Rest of Us Healthy?
Jonathan Zittrain
The Case Materials
Zeran v. AOL (W.D. Ok)
Complaint
Zeran v. AOL (W.D. Ok)
Order on Motion to Transfer
Zeran v. AOL (E.D. Va)
Memorandum in Support of Defendant’s Motion For Judgment on the Pleadings
Zeran v. AOL (E.D. Va)
Brief in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion For Judgment on the Pleadings
Zeran v. AOL (E.D. Va)
Reply Memorandum in Further Support of Defendant’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings
Zeran v. AOL (E.D. Va) Court Hearing Transcript
Opinion in Zeran v. AOL (E.D. Va)
Zeran v. AOL (4th Cir.)
Brief of the Appellant
Zeran v. AOL (4th Cir.)
Brief of the Appellee
Zeran v. AOL (4th Cir.)
Opinion
Zeran’s Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
Opposition of America Online, Inc. to Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
Zeran’s Reply to Opposition to Petition for a Writ of Certiorari
Zeran v. Diamond Broadcasting, Inc. (W.D. Ok)
Opinion
Zeran v. Diamond Broadcasting, Inc. (10th Cir.)
Opinion
Pingback: News of the Week; December 2, 2020 – Communications Law at Allard Hall()