Copyright Lawsuits Over Embedding Are Still a Thing
After the Ninth Circuit’s Hunley v. Instagram ruling in 2023, I naively assumed that the case established essential precedent that would quickly end other legal challenges to embedding. WRONG! The anti-embedding cases seem to be going strong, especially in SDNY….
YouTuber Loses Account Suspension Case Again–Hall v. YouTube
This is a futile account termination/content removal case, like dozens before it. Prior blog post. So I’m blogging this ruling for completion, not significance. After the prior dismissal, the YouTuber filed an amended complaint: The FAC complains that YouTube engaged…
Twitter’s TOS Formation Upheld–Taddeo-Waite v. X
TL;DR: a court upheld X’s TOS formation. This is not a new or surprising result, especially against a pro se plaintiff. * * * The plaintiff claims that Twitter failed to remove a post about his young daughter. He sued…
Another Facebook Account Termination, Another Failed Lawsuit–Karam v. Meta
This is a pro se case. The court summarizes: “Meta purportedly banned or restricted [Karam’s] Facebook account, which allegedly prevented him from advertising his business or from engaging with potential customers through Marketplace or Facebook’s Buy/Sell Groups.” The court dismisses…
Section 230 Applies to Scammy Ads–Glazer v. Facebook
The plaintiff is octogenarian Barry Glazer, an attorney who has a fascinating history of running TV ads and who sells merch at his website that includes his tagline “Don’t urinate on my leg and tell me it’s raining.” [Note: If…
Online TOS Formation Cases Make My Head Hurt
Coverage of two TOS formation cases that hit my alerts this week. Walsh v. Dollar Tree Store, Inc., 2025 WL 2939229 (S.D. Cal. Oct. 16, 2025) Dollar Tree required all website visitors to navigate through an interstitial cookie wall before…
The Wrap Taxonomy Vexes the Judge in the LinkedIn Insight Tag Cases
In the LinkedIn “Insight Tag” cases, Judge Davila issued two opinions where he classified UIs into the Wrap Taxonomy–and left a trail of appeallable issues in his wake. L.W.A. v. LinkedIn Corp., 2025 WL 2780788 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 30, 2025)…
Court Fetishizes Facebook’s TOS Statement That It Takes “Appropriate” Content Moderation Actions–Calise v. Meta
This is the remand of the disastrous Ninth Circuit decision, where a TAFS judge launched a wrecking ball into the Ninth Circuit’s Section 230 jurisprudence. When the dust settled, the 9th Circuit ruling enables plaintiffs to plead around Section 230…
512(f) Claim Sent to Trial (Which Didn’t Happen)–Leszczynski v. Kitchen Cube
[My standard lament that Westlaw’s indexing of Central District of California cases is unusually laggy.] Tomas Leszczynski claimed to have created the Bakercube Measuring Cube. He posted the 3D printing instructions for the cube to the Internet, subject to a…
Another TOS Formation Fails–Carruth v. Big Little Feelings
This is a Meta Pixels case. The plaintiff alleged VPPA violations. 🙄 The defense sought to send the case to arbitration per its TOS. The court disagrees. The Mobile Interface In its moving papers, the defense provided the following screengrab…