How Can AI Models Legally Obtain Training Data?–Doe 1 v. GitHub (Guest Blog Post)
by guest blogger Kieran McCarthy Doe 1 v. GitHub, Inc. is one of the first major class-action lawsuits to dive into questions of online collection of “public data” and generative AI training data sets. Given the importance of generative AI…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28dbe/28dbe838dea1dab3ef89d879b2cdedd275a27af6" alt="Class Certification Denied Over Rightsowners' Demands for Content ID Access--Schneider v. YouTube"
Class Certification Denied Over Rightsowners’ Demands for Content ID Access–Schneider v. YouTube
The court summarizes the case: “plaintiffs allege that YouTube has violated the copyright laws by withholding broad access to Content ID….Plaintiffs also allege that YouTube automatically strips metadata out of uploaded videos, including copyright management information (CMI), which makes it…
Amazon Screws Up Its TOS Amendments (Again)–Jackson v. Amazon
This case involves “Amazon Flex” drivers. Allegedly, “Amazon monitored and wiretapped the drivers’ conversations when they communicated during off hours in closed Facebook groups.” Amazon claimed its TOS mandated arbitration. The Ninth Circuit disagrees. At issue are two versions of…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af088/af0881a215507cdd3f64d1892b6fb17c140d5a46" alt="Microsoft Can Terminate User Account for Allegedly Possessing CSAM. But What If It Made a Mistake?--Deutsch v. Microsoft"
Microsoft Can Terminate User Account for Allegedly Possessing CSAM. But What If It Made a Mistake?–Deutsch v. Microsoft
The plaintiff (a NY lawyer/financial executive?) allegedly uploaded CSAM to his Microsoft OneDrive folder in violation of Microsoft’s “Code of Conduct.” [Nomenclature note: CSAM is what used to be called child porn; the case calls it CSEAI]. Allegedly, PhotoDNA detected…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8b761/8b761c7de51e9cd27917741846bedc93b6dab1aa" alt="Do Mandatory Age Verification Laws Conflict with Biometric Privacy Laws?--Kuklinski v. Binance"
Do Mandatory Age Verification Laws Conflict with Biometric Privacy Laws?–Kuklinski v. Binance
California passed the California Age-Appropriate Design Code (AADC) nominally to protect children’s privacy, but at the same time, the AADC requires businesses to do an age “assurance” of all their users, children and adults alike. (Age “assurance” requires the business…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/33420/33420cf2bb1d07880826baded905df9f796b11c4" alt="After hiQ Labs, Is Scraping Public Data Legal? (Guest Blog Post)"
After hiQ Labs, Is Scraping Public Data Legal? (Guest Blog Post)
by guest blogger Kieran McCarthy Last year, the most important case in the history of web scraping—hiQ Labs, Inc. v. LinkedIn Corp.—settled. After two trips to the 9th Circuit, a remand from the Supreme Court, and nearly six years of…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8df27/8df272f0d18375c4f962c59b1e011e9ed50a37a5" alt="Form "Non-Disparagement" Clause Violated Consumer Review Fairness Act--State v. Ideal Horizon Benefits"
Form “Non-Disparagement” Clause Violated Consumer Review Fairness Act–State v. Ideal Horizon Benefits
In 2016, Congress enacted the Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA), which bans businesses from trying to contractually restrict their customers’ reviews. It represents a rare federal intervention into contract law, and it does so for good reasons–to reduce the ability…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b099/4b09919d99ad118fe64bd4115044205f5290d2f3" alt="A Preliminary Analysis of Trump's Copyright Lawsuit Over Interview Recordings (Trump v. Simon & Schuster) (Guest Blog Post)"
A Preliminary Analysis of Trump’s Copyright Lawsuit Over Interview Recordings (Trump v. Simon & Schuster) (Guest Blog Post)
By Guest Blogger Tyler Ochoa [Eric’s note: Prof. Ochoa calls this a “preliminary” analysis, but that doesn’t mean it’s short!] Two weeks ago, former President Donald Trump filed a lawsuit against journalist Bob Woodward and his publisher, Simon & Schuster…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a00e4/a00e4a0b8b02b16b83bbf2caa7d4310b9688b23d" alt="If You Ask Your Friend to Take Your Photo Using Your Camera, Who Owns the Copyright?--Shah v. NYP"
If You Ask Your Friend to Take Your Photo Using Your Camera, Who Owns the Copyright?–Shah v. NYP
Vivek Shah attended several Hollywood parties. While there, he preset the settings on his phone camera (including shutter speed, white balance, ISO, metering type, and exposure value) and asked friends or bystanders to use his phone to take photos of…
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f589f/f589f53318751d04e228fa80c2adb2e809566c58" alt="2022 Internet Law Year-in-Review"
2022 Internet Law Year-in-Review
Three dynamics combined to make 2022 a brutal year for Internet Law. First, the techlash is taking its toll. There is widespread belief that the major incumbents are too big, too rich, and too capricious to avoid pervasive government control….