Too Many Courts Are Letting States Take Wrecking Balls to the Internet (Roundup)

‘Tis the season for Internet censorship. 🎄 More accurately, Internet censorship is now a four-season sport in state legislatures. There is not a stereotypical red state/blue state divide. Instead, the “divide” is between pro-censorship and anti-censorship legislators. You can count…

Texas Judge Enjoins App Store Authentication Law--CCIA and SEAT v. Paxton

This blog post involves two near-identical cases challenging the Texas App Store Accountability Act, Senate Bill 2420 (“SB 2420” or “the Act”), Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 121.001 et seq. SB 2420 is a robust multi-pronged segregate-and-suppress law that…

Google Can Assert a DMCA 512(d) Defense--Cengage v. Google (Catch-Up Post)

Textbook publishers are suing Google for its alleged role in facilitating what they consider to be mass piracy. In June 2025, the court partially denied Google’s motion to dismiss. Still remaining in the case are the plaintiffs’ contributory copyright infringement…

Appeals Court Accepts That the "Water" Emoji Can Be Slang for Methamphetamine--U.S. v. Reed

This is a federal prosecution against alleged drug dealers. There is substantial evidence beyond the emojis suggesting that Swanagan is a dealer. Prior blog post. The appeals court didn’t quote Swanagan’s inculpatory message in full. Here it is from the…

District Court Again Rejects Plaintiffs' Attempts to Manufacture Common Law Notice-and-Takedown Duties--Bogard v. TikTok

This is a quirky lawsuit designed to subvert Section 230, the First Amendment, and traditional common law. I previously summarized the case: This lawsuit purports to focuses on the allegedly defective operation of the services’ reporting tools, but the plaintiffs’…

Courts Enjoin Internet Censorship Laws in Louisana and Arkansas

[I have a mondo draft roundup blog post, coming soon, covering a lot of segregate-and-suppress rulings. For now, I’ve prioritized coverage of these two rulings due to their importance. I’ll discuss the Louisiana law first, then the Arkansas law. Warning:…

OnlyFans Defeats "Chatter Scam" Claim--N.Z. v. Fenix

The court summarizes the plaintiffs’ “chatter scam” contentions: Plaintiffs allege that Fenix Defendants, in cooperation with the Agency Defendants, operate a fraudulent scheme whereby Fenix Defendants charge OnlyFans subscribers to communicate directly with creators, purport to connect subscribers with creators,…

Post-Mortem of a Misguided Logo Trademark Lawsuit--LegalForce v. Internet Brands

The plaintiff in this case is LegalForce, Raj Abhyanker CEO, which run the notorious trademark registration operation Trademarkia. How notorious? Trademarkia’s own web site has a page entitled “Is Trademarkia a Scam? Debunking Hearsay,” which brings to mind the old…

Second Circuit Rejects Email Service on Chinese Defendants in Baby Shark SAD Scheme Case

This case involves the “Baby Shark” earworm song, which has billions of YouTube views and ranks as the #1 most viewed YouTube video of all time. You already know the lyrics (and associated hand/arm movements) by heart, but the high-quality…

Is Blogging a "Recreational Activity"?--Sander v. Westchester Reform Temple

In 2021, Jessie Sander was hired as a Jewish educator at the Westchester Reform Temple, located in Scarsdale, NY. Sander calls the temple a “Zionist institution.” The temple’s website still publicly espouses support for Israel. Shortly after she was hired,…