Section 230 protection should then be conditional on the ICS providing all available information on the bad actor upon request.

Yes, I’m sure that this provides comfort and closure for those on the receiving end of persistent targeted harassment and threats on social media, but cannot find the bad actors thanks to them using anonymous burner accounts.

Telling people “Oh, you just don’t understand the law!” is insulting to the intelligence of those that understand the law but recognize that finding and holding bad actors accountable can at times be nigh-on impossible.

But I guess as someone that argues that Section 230 should defend the right of Amazon to allow fly-by-night vendors to sell defective products on Amazon and face no liability for it when injured parties are unable to get into contact with the vanishing vendors, you don’t actually care.